Yes, that high-pitched whine
you hear is Dan O’Bannon’s coffin spinning out of the grave and into low orbit.
I watched the second half of the ALIEN:
EARTH TV show. (From episode five on, I wrote escape capsule hit-pieces as
episodes aired, just so you know.)
In my
earlier blog post on the first four episodes, I wrote that the key feature of
any story featuring the ALIEN
franchise is this: at some point, smart people in space must do dumb things for
the story to move forward.
Damn it. Episode five acknowledges this in
the script itself. Proof of how stupid
smart people can be. It’s built into the story. Too close to the alien
bone?
Now…I glossed over a whole bunch of things
from the first four episodes. Take episode four, for example. In which Battle
Angel Alita Wendy Darling becomes an alien snake-charmer. Or something. She
can talk to the animals.
But it is time to return to those earlier
episodes in talking about smart people in space doing dumb things. In episode
one, you get the idea that something goes horribly wrong on the spaceship that
looks awfully like Ridley Scott’s idea of a spaceship on the inside.
But we aren’t shown that story.
We see glimpses of the set.
A load of viewers believed…if you build a whole set and don’t show the
story in full, then there’ll be a flashback episode later. Explaining all
of that nasty stuff in gory detail. As sure as chest-bursting follows a meal,
that’s what we got in episode five. Must use the set. Built it for something.
Use it.
There were hints in earlier episodes of what
went down. But we really must see the whole thing. And this is the point at
which Dan O’Bannon’s coffin achieves escape velocity.
Here’s the flashback set-up. Two aliens
escape their containment pods. They hug faces. One member of the crew dies in
an ill-advised surgical procedure. Acid, baby. The other is placed in a
cryogenic suspension pod.
Oopsie.
The alien bursts out of that chest and flees
the pod. Glass breaks when the plot demands. Hiding in the vast ship, somewhere,
the alien creates the perfect set-up for an alien jailbreak. This li’l alien
can sneak through vents and ignore holes in the plot or some shit, and reaches
the other aliens in their safe glass containers. Mm.
That would be okay. Believable, if you
squint hard enough. One alien slithers in, fucks shit up, and slithers out
again. I’d buy that. But I’m not purchasing what actually happens. The aliens
in the lab stage a jailbreak by opening their prisons from the inside.
They’re smarter than the average bear, see.
This is dumber than a box of moon rocks. Use
the alien that already fucking escaped. Let it wreak havoc in the lab. It’s the
alien, for fuck’s sake. But…no. When
these other aliens aren’t solving the Times
crossword or Mr Rubik’s fiendish cube, they are staging a jailbreak. By…
Now this bit is the worst bit in the
episode. Breaks all the rules. It is drummed into anyone who ever sat in a
science class. And it applies to the lab. NO FOOD AND DRINK
IN THE LAB. Ever. True, this is an ALIEN gig…so smart people must do dumb things in space for the
story to move forward over a cliff.
There’s a lot in earlier episodes set up to
pay off in this flashback, and then advance the story by switching to the here
and now. But the golden opporchancity was there, and they blew it. Let the
alien, from ALIEN, do its alien thing
in fucking shit up. Then the new aliens can cut loose and do their alien thing.
Don’t keep sidelining the original monster.
Instead, we see the Skullfucker Octoball try
to take on the adult alien. But there aren’t any eyes to pluck out. As fucking
expected. At the end of the episode, we dip back into BLADE RUNNER territory with the appearance of Lady Yutani…and, for
once, she isn’t on the phone to Mr Morrow the cyborg. She’s there, in person,
with a bunch of mad-looking corporate samurai dudes. Send in the clones. Don’t
worry. They’re here.
The ALIEN
movie gave us an alien horror with a dose of corporate evil thrown in. Here,
the corporate comedy hijinks take the main BLADE
RUNNER stage. In flashback land, there’s a saboteur on board, ooh, blasting
bits of the spaceship into the cosmos.
I’m surprised the alien didn’t just turn to
the camera and ask the audience what the fuck it was doing here. In Michael
Caine’s accent.
You’re
only supposed to blow the bloody doors off.
It’s one of those TV shows. If you can’t
work out which of these characters we are meant to care for, root for the
alien.
Am I meant to care for Mark Musk Elon
Zuckerberg and his obsession with Battle Angel Alita Wendy Darling? I’d
have preferred a woman in the role of the trillionaire. Blonde. With a
roll-neck sweater and a fixation over Steve Jobs.
Her company, being in the ALIEN universe, has to be called Theranos Thanatos. I still
wouldn’t care about the character, but there’d be far more scope for comedy.
Yes, it’s true. I’ve watched these episodes, and…I only care about the original
alien. Neglected. Ignored. Forgotten. Sliced up. Missing in action. And then
lit brightly in a fucking fish tank.
When we reach episode five and a flashback
containing some xenomorph action, we are treated to microwaved leftovers from
an earlier cinematic experience. A flurry of half-hearted positive reviews out
there in the dark all mutter out of the side of the mouth when declaring…
You
know, we’ve had worse out of this franchise.
And so on. This is, at heartless heart, The Emperor’s New Skinsuit. The only
thing connecting ALIEN to BLADE RUNNER is the director who used
similar production techniques and items in both films.
So why turn this ALIEN TV show into BLADE
RUNNER by another name? Yes, it has been strangely watchable. I could be at
the top of a skyscraper, on the corner, looking down on a police chase on
Strangely
watchable. And there’s nothing I can do about it except look away. But I
look. Would this show reach physical media? Disney releases are patchy and
unpredictable, that way. Would I buy a 4K set? No. This is one…and very done.
There are loads of ALIEN and PREDATOR films
out there that I didn’t buy. I’m pretty sure I didn’t even watch a bunch of the
PREDATOR ones. ALIEN should never have been a franchise. Luckily, HIGHLANDER was never a franchise.
Fortunately, THE MATRIX was a
one-off. And
BACK
TO THE FUTURE stuck to the plan. No more movies after the third one. Sadly,
over my dead body might apply here
once Zemeckis hangs up his director’s hat for the very last time. No one is
going to remake that story with the main character as Marsha McFly. The crush
sub-plot was icky enough with Marty.
(Also, technically, the main character in BACK TO THE
FUTURE is the most important time traveller – the dog.)
What of ALIEN:
THE WILDERNESS YEARS as a franchise? Battle
Angel Wendy. FAUX RUNNER. Do Androids Dream of Monsters Under the Bed?
I should go on, but you get the point. Oh, very well. ASLAN VERSUS ALIEN VERSUS PREDATOR VERSUS CALVIN AND HOBBES: MA’AM,
THIS IS A WENDY’S. Now I’m done.
We have Wendy the snake-charmer or The Alien Whisperer. I suspect a lot of
the show is going nowhere. And no more is this evident than in episode six. The Fluff. It’s an episode about padding
and nothing much going on. If that.
Once more, we question basic lab techniques.
No one should be alone in the lab. And the aliens should all really have a lab each. Think the show missed a trick,
there. Each alien needs its own unique lab.
Yes, give each lab a sense of character and
an alien in it. At least then the show would have some character. But no, we’ll
keep these lions in one room and in glass cases. Yes, if you were paying
attention in the previous episodes that didn’t lull you to sleep, then you’d
know there’s this other alien. Awaiting a slow tease of an appearance.
And we get to the goods in this episode. Not
worth the wait. The central plank of creating your superhero team, those lost
boys and girls, is giving the audience synthetic characters who aren’t affected
by the aliens. Creating synthetic characters. There’s an idea that’s a hostage
to fortune.
Superheroes aren’t affected by the aliens. Except…this
is an ALIEN franchise offshoot, and
so we’ll be fucking around with that expectation more than once. Battle
Angel Wendy got into a tussle with an alien and lived to tell the tale.
She’s all better now.
In this episode, we see feeding time at the
zoo go horribly wrong for a synthetic character we don’t have energy to care
for. Dolly the sheep just sheeps in, fucks shit up, and sheeps some more.
The Skullfucker Octoball in charge of the
sheep is biding its time, playing tenth-dimensional chess, and shit. Oh no. The
CGI fly eats wobots for bweakfast. For a top secret research facility, I notice
the cameras on
Characters stumble around in and out of
various situations. The Veronica Cartwright Veronica Cartwright
character was damaged but she’s all better now. They gave her a mind-wipe, but
didn’t warn anyone else on the island about not telling her that. So now she
knows she had a mind-wipe after being told. Would have been better off with a
facecloth and some mild soap.
Inevitably, after much padding, and more fan
service out of focus in the background, we reach the hugging of a face. And
when this face was hugged, I found it hard not to laugh out loud. I
half-expected the actor to start moonwalking, and I just couldn’t take it
seriously.
What’s that? The guy who was fired in this
episode didn’t make it off the island? Instead he was dragged into one of those
standard air vents large enough to fit several plot holes through? Explain why
the secure lab needs a massive ALIEN AIR
VENT™ at floor level. Or, indeed, at any level. Explain. Show your working.
There were so many other ways to build up to
SOME CHARACTER WE DON’T CARE ABOUT™
being hugged in the face by an alien. I say we take off and nuke the entire show
from orbit. It’s the only way to be sure.
Damn.
It’s sad seeing the alien in a well-lit glass
cage doing sweet fuck-all. Not an ALIEN
moment. The same is true of the actress playing Lady Yutani. She finally gets
her teeth into a scene. Regrettably, it’s a scene from a BLADE RUNNER show no one asked for.
All the padding, all the waffle, questioning
what it is to be human…the fluff belongs in another type of story. Is there a
place for it here? There is. In small doses. But not as padding. So much for
episode six, which, in the closing seconds, attempts to make the Skullfucker
Octoball the star of this show.
IT ISN’T.
What stays with me in this episode?
Pointlessness. There’s a talk about what Wendy will do. She could be family to
her brother. But there are loftier goals. She should develop travel faster than
the speed of light, and explore the universe. Wendy must make the right choice.
Except…there’s nothing to stop her eternal
self being family to her brother until he
dies of old age. Then she can explore the universe after. She can have it
all. It isn’t EITHER/OR. The show
flounders arse-deep in too many moments like that.
And then there was episode seven.
Two of the Very Lost Boys lead their pal the
scientist dude into the jungle. Basically, Lennie is being taken to see the
rabbits. (Spoiler for another story.) The Peter
Pan framework should have been referenced with a light touch. Too late for
that. The whole show lumbers along, top-heavy with enforced symbolism.
You’d be better off watching The Lost Boys. That’s a movie about
rebellious Kiefer Sutherland being all rebellious and shit.
The different spaghetti strands of
storytelling veer off and converge just about as messily as you’d expect. Those
behind the show have certainly seen the movie Predator. So it is time to throw in a bit of that in the jungle.
But not too much, lest the show be accused of turning into Predator.
Normally I’d say Wendy’s plan comes across
as one of the worst plans in the history of science fiction television. But I
can’t stop there. Wendy’s plan is one of the worst plans in the history of
plans.
I’ll release
my tame alien as a distraction, so we can escape
Again, we come back to this thing of the
alien in a glass cage, sidelined by the shenanigans elsewhere. Characters queue
up in slow motion, waiting for death. When death comes, it arrives with CGI
rapidity.
They know, making this show, that scenes of
the alien escaping and killing lab techs in bright light…well, those scenes are
just not going to cut it. So we’ll switch to the security cameras, for a more
obscured look at the CGI tomfoolery.
And so it goes, again, when in the jungle.
An instant problem arrives. Soldiers. An instant fix arrives. Predator.
The alien. This time the fight is in broad daylight, so we have to obscure our
alien by using the bushes.
Perhaps more than any other episode, this
episode feels like it is about to (chest) burst into being a musical. Soldiers
with bad timing turn up to miss the main event. Characters with no planning
flit in and out of sight.
It takes a very long forty minutes for
Wendy, Veronica Cartwright Veronica Cartwright, and Communist Manifesto
Guy from ANDOR to reach the boat, the boat, and we don’t even
have Mr Roarke or Tattoo standing by to wave them farewell.
There’s one episode to watch. Before it
airs, I wonder what it sets up. This whole show is about a mission to bring
alien samples back for study. But even that
mission was off the back of an earlier unseen sequence in which a whole bunch
of people died. We were told this.
So we may yet see another prequel. Where are we, by episode seven? Number of deaths
so far? Don’t care. Number of characters worth caring about? Don’t care.
Trillionaire-ism is bad. Corporations are bad. People are no better. Just bet
on the alien for the win.
What else didn’t I care about on the show?
Screens. They flashed up with information on the aliens. We live in a TV age of
visuals that are clear enough. You can pause the data dumps and read snippets
of what the aliens are all about.
And I just didn’t care. We’re told about the
Skullfucker Octoball. And we’re told about the really fucking boring plant
thing. I’m waiting on the base being overrun by plants when the inevitable
fire/explosion sequence kicks in. And then the killer plant can really go to
work. Presuming it crawls into a handy ventilation shaft where it can survive
the fire/explosion.
No, I didn’t care about the text screens.
They could have flashed Surprised in the
Butt by Ripley’s Xenomorph Lover: a Chuck Tingle Dinosaur Romance on one of
those screens for all the difference those screens made.
And so. To episode ate eight. The
scenewy’s pwetty. Be vewy vewy quiet. I’m hunting humans wabbits humans
wabbits for a story. We go a li’l bit Predator, a li’l bit country, a li’l bit rock ’n’ roll, and a bit Terminator 2.
Two Terminator machines go at it in a lab,
in a rather inconsequential fight…in an inconsequential episode. This is the
last episode in the show, and I expected the deaths to mount up. Instead, we
had a whole lot of nothing.
Okay. There were deaths. Soldiers, on the
island, dying under the alien’s teeth and claws. Don’t forget the tail. There’s
a good story here, stumbling through the ruins of other stories. I can see what
they were trying to go for. Alas…
The entire episode does, indeed, act as
set-up for the next series. I expected a whole bunch of characters to die. You
have practically the whole bunch in a room. One bomb and it is done. But no.
Yutani doesn’t even get to phone in her
performance here. She’s flashed up on the screen as a reminder of her
existence. There was so much noodling around, too much padding, for the late
arrival of her army to make a difference.
That army should have arrived earlier in the
story, full force, with chaos the result. Chaos in which the monsters get to
feed. Here’s an idea. In the future, just have jail cells that are locked the
old-fashioned way. With a physical key. Don’t operate the cages by electricity.
It’s the dumbest thing. All the creatures,
and the other prisoners in this narrative, are locked in electrically-powered
jails. What if the power goes? There’s a back-up. What if the back-up goes?
NOTHING. The fucking doors stay locked, you cunts!
Wait. Let me tell you how I really feel.
Welcome to
Everyone is in a rush to be the next model, rendering the last model
obsolete. That notion does a few handstands and backflips as characters
manoeuvre around each other…to no great effect.
The Peter
Pan stuff sputtered out episodes ago. Boy Genius isn’t Peter Pan. He’s
a symbolic coded fictional watercolour painting of Elon Musk
refusing to accept an autistic
trans daughter.
Misunderstood. He’s misunderstood. And irritating. We don’t even get his plan
out of his lips.
He sends the minds of children into
artificial bodies. They’ll have access to the whole of human learning. And they
can then improve the process so that adult minds can transfer into human
bodies. That’s when Elon Zuckerberg makes his move. But that isn’t even a plot
here.
There’s a movie worth watching to reach a
conclusion about the handling of the Boy Genius in this show…
The
Dirty Dozen. In that film, one of the dozen is the character you love to
hate. You cannot wait for Archer Maggott to die. When’s he getting shot? That’s Archer Maggot’s story right there.
And so it should be with the Boy Genius. He
serves no purpose beyond being set up as an evil doll-figure who is
bitch-slapped by an alien at just the right time. Boy Genius deserves to be on
the way out by episode three.
Even that Veronica Cartwright
Veronica Cartwright character, who appeared to die in episode seven, made it
back for episode eight. The two mad scientists assisting the Boy Genius are
still in play by the end of this show. And, spoiler, one of them is dead.
Adrian Edmondson, as some sort of cybernetic
Odd Job henchman, minus the bowler
hat, is still ticking along merrily by the end as well.
Yes, the killer plant finally makes its
move, and this is as underwhelming as you’d expect. That played out like a
random encounter with a Dungeons &
Dragons monster in a killer dungeon.
All dungeons are killer dungeons, whether
science fiction or fantasy. In this killer dungeon, though, the usual suspects
make it through. It’s almost as though there’s some evil hidden agenda. An evil
corporate agenda. To produce another series.
You had one job, television. One job. To
make sure the alien would kill a whole lotta people (and synthetics) in a show
that sidelined the alien in favour of letting a whole lotta people (and
synthetics) live. The final episode could’ve done with being a bit more final.
This TV show sounds a bit like an earlier
spin-off. ALIEN: EARTH isn’t a comic
book series. ALIENS: EARTH WAR is. I
enjoyed the raw energy of those comic book stories. This TV blip has a hard
task, true…
There shouldn’t be a franchise, yet there
is. So what’s the problem? Trade on the original story. Add something new.
Avoid fan service. Remember when? We
fucking do. Stop reminding us.
We want the familiar, but it must be
different. Advance on it. But not too different. So you won’t satisfy any audience. There are people out there in
deep space, declaring there is only one ALIEN
movie. There certainly shouldn’t be two television shows.
We don’t need to see Ian Holm’s acting dug
up from the vaults in some nonsensical scene. (I know I’ve seen that travesty,
but I refused to believe it.) If you must give us something, give us something
of substance. Evil Trillionaire Boy Genius could have experimented on the alien
and realised that – if you solve the acid problem – then the alien blood might cure
cancer.
That would be a better twist than anything,
everything, on this show. Was there a scrap of merit? Discovering the lost boys
and girls had their own graveyard on
Imagine watching a TV show and then turning
to Mark Verhieden’s comic books for something bright, fiery, and with its own
peculiar atmosphere. Those comics had the same hard task. Give us more of the
same, but not too samey. Verhieden was allowed to use the characters of Newt
and Hicks…
Until a shitty movie sequel came along and
killed them off. Then the names were changed to protect the indifferent. They
were changed back for the collected editions.
So, yes, there was a bit of fan service in
the comic books. But Verhieden tried to give us the atmosphere of an ALIEN story. Not a BLADE RUNNER one or a TERMINATOR
one. Or Peter Pan with robots thrown
in.
The television show feels sterile. Airless.
Unloved. It feels unwatched even as you watch it, and that’s no good. My view,
after watching? I turned to the comic books for a better experience.
What surprised me? That I watched every
episode. Please. For fuck’s sake. Don’t make a second show.
RLLauthor@outlook.com and @RLL_author GO TO AMAZON KINDLE STORE AND TYPE RLL. YOU WILL FIND MY BOOKS.
Wednesday, 1 October 2025
THE HIGH-PITCHED WHINE OF DAN O’BANNON’S COFFIN: A REPORT FROM A FUGITIVE.
Thursday, 10 October 2024
EMPTY STAR WARS TELEVISION: A REPORT FROM A FUGITIVE.
There is no spoon, and there never was one. Second and third
spoons need not apply. (Plays ROGUE ONE
soundtrack in the background. That’s not commentary or subtext. ROGUE ONE has its faults, its high points:
I just chose a soundtrack at semi-random.)
Fans of THE ACOLYTE …look away, now. If you
enjoy the show, enjoy it while looking away from this area.
Where to begin with
a non-show in which nothing much happens? Nothing much happens. That’s a non-spoiler
non-alert. I was waiting for the show to start when it reached its predictable
end in episode eight.
THE ACOLYTE. We need a bit of
background. Not much. This show is set in a galaxy that’s long ago and, oh, so far away. I
fell in love with you before the second show. (Shout out to Darth Coolidge,
Darth Bramlett, Darth Russell, and Darth Carpenter for the song tie-in.)
That’s true. STAR WARS is my thing. But I didn’t fall
in love with THE ACOLYTE before the
second show. Typically, almost a law for Disney STAR WARS, the TV show dropped with more than one episode on release
day. And it kept on dropping.
Spoiler. I didn’t
fall in love with THE ACOLYTE after
the second show. By the eighth, I wondered if I’d just seen the first
zero-content TV series connected to STAR
WARS. You may argue that other zero-content shows preceded this one. Who am
I to stand in your way…
To the deep space background,
then. STAR WARS gives us a story
about the Jedi: interplanetary hippie peaceniks who will, on occasion, dish out
death-pain with big sticks of buzzy light.
The Jedi are in decline, all but extinct,
roundly beaten up, and stomped down by the Sith – enemies of all the good
things Jedi believe in. A once great Galactic Republic turned into an Evil Empire™ overnight. With a little
help from Sith operating in the shadows, you understand.
Yes, the Jedi are
done. But it’s time to fight back. And so, we get STAR WARS movies. At first, three of them. And the word Sith isn’t mentioned once. The actor Don
Henderson says the word in a deleted scene from the first movie. I find the
lack of its inclusion disturbing.
Later, that first
movie became episode four. And we had three more movies set before it. Easy as 1,
2, 3. Except, there’s a spin-off that links episode three to episode four: ROGUE ONE. That makes it episode four,
even though it has ONE in the title,
and the first movie that became episode four is now the fifth film in the
series.
To watch them in
order, that’s 1, 2, 3, ROGUE ONE, 4,
5, and 6. I have them in 4K and still can’t bring myself to watch 7, 8, and 9
again. It’s going to take an effort. I feel they have to follow on from all the
other movies, and that’s a hell of a binge.
There’s another
spin-off with the character Han Solo. That should be after 3 and before ROGUE ONE. It sits off to the side.
No one counts those
Ewok movies. On television, there are
many many episodes of spin-off shows.
They flit in and out of the main history. Basically, the primary space thrust
of the timeline is…
Okay, 4, 5, and 6
tell the story. Then 1, 2, and 3 fill in the gaps BEFORE. The concept of BEFORE is important. Jump back around a
hundred years before the movie series to the televisual time of THE ACOLYTE. The evil Empire does not
yet exist. There are no Sith, and there haven’t been any Sith for a long time, a long time.
The Jedi preside over the Republic as
peacekeepers. Cops. Space Samurai. You get the idea. Oh, and there are no Sith.
Did I mention a complete lack of Sith? This is what the Republic believed.
Before the Dark Times…before Darth Lucas sold the property.
But they were all
of them deceived. For another ring
was made.
Hang on…wrong saga.
Everyone was
deceived. If the Jedi are Space Samurai, and they are, then the Sith are interplanetary
spies. Robbers. Space Ninja. You get the idea.
I’d never heard of
the Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
On this side of the Atlantic there’s the Health
and Safety Executive. HSE is also
a virus that’ll fuck you up. It’s nasty.
Anyway, I think HSE looks like just the right sort of
name for a Sith character. Greetings,
Darth Hse. And you brought the ruins of the battle-droid, I see. Your little
joke. We Sith are known for our humour, after all.
Insert EVIL CACKLE™ there.
But THE ACOLYTE went with Osha instead. She’s all about health and
safety in the workplace. This isn’t generally true of STAR WARS. The saga is full of high walkways with no safety
barriers or railings. It’s a science fiction scandal. I’ve asked fellow delegate
Binks to arrange emergency powers in the Senate. That should fix a lot of upward
mobility problems.
So. This television
show is STAR WARS way before STAR WARS. That’s been done. There’s a
whole prequel trilogy covering old ground, remember. But this goes way back
before all that. It’s an even longer time ago in the same galaxy we’ve seen
already. Before the before.
If the Republic is
doing well, and it’ll be a Republic for a science fiction lifetime yet, then
what are the stakes in a story set in the deeper past? Where’s the risk? Can
you point me in the direction of the drama? So many options here. Let’s not go
with a limiting choice…oh.
There’ll be Jedi.
And they will investigate criminal stuff. Not the regular crime beat. The tough
cases. Crime Scene Investigation: Scum
and Villainy. But what are the stakes, though? Where’s the conflict? Will
we see any operatic drama in our Space Opera? (There is no conflict.)
This is a hundred
years before STAR WARS. You aren’t
going to change history, here. Yes, made-up STAR
WARS history, but, y’know, still history. We are going to see the Jedi
investigate things. Don’t quite know what.
And there will be
Sith. Except that there aren’t any Sith.
Shock horror, the
Sith were around the whole time. Lurking. Skulking. Sneaking. Gollum wasn’t sneaking! Er…maybe he was,
after all. We’ll get to that bit.
Okay. We know from STAR WARS movies that, near the end of
the Republic, Sith haven’t been seen for AGES. True story. From a certain point
of view. We have the word of the cone-headed Jedi. So it must be true. I
searched for cone-head Jedi to reach
video clips confirming this.
If a STAR WARS character in a STAR WARS movie isn’t named aloud in a STAR WARS movie, any name attached to
the character is only listed in the closing credits to plug the merchandise
related to that character. A tale of many action figures. That’s an old song.
If lucky, the character is named eventually on film, somewhere down the line.
A world-weary view,
you say. I don’t make the merchandising contracts.
Ki-Adi-Mundi, Mr
Cone-head, tells us the Sith have been
extinct for a millennium. He does this in a movie. His emphasis on the
timespan is irrelevant. There was a time when the Dodo had been extinct for
five minutes. Dodo ain’t coming back unless someone pulls some Jurassic Park shit with…actual preserved
Dodo shit and questionable midichlorian sperm samples.
Once the Empire is
a thing, the Imperials go around announcing the Jedi are all but extinct.
Everyone keeps messing this up when considering absent enemy forces. We haven’t
seen any. They are clearly dead. Most
sincerely dead, as averred by the coroner. What’s the point?
The point is this.
In STAR WARS history, the Sith are
gone. They were hiding. The Sith agents make a surprising return and create an Evil Empire™ out of confusion and chaos.
So far, so good...concerning the bad.
And so…in the before the before part of this history, back
a hundred years you go into television land, you have a problem.
In THE ACOLYTE, way before the Dark Times,
before the Empire, you can’t throw Sith into the story that’s set ages before
all the upheaval. UNLESS. You show Sith
skulking in the shadows, being Space Ninja Bastards. (This gets too literal at
the end of the show, when Gollum turns up and does a bit of sneaking.)
What if the bad
guys are discovered? As a writing choice, you must then wipe out all the good
guys who discover the bad guys. This is a basic building block of any story you
attempt to tell in that manner, just to preserve the (made-up) history.
Reminder of that
history. The Sith were destroyed. Then they turned up and created an Empire of
pure EVIL. They used the element of surprise to plan a load of shit, before
they were discovered too late to stop huge events already long in motion.
Setting a story
before they arrive on the scene is okay…as long as no one knows they’ve arrived
on the scene way before.
Just do
Ninja Missions. Have close calls and dramatic escapes under the distracted eyes
of the pesky Space Samurai. Make the show heavy on the viewpoint of the Sith.
It’s about the baddies as the main characters. Yes. Do that.
Setting the story
BEFORE the other bit BEFORE, you have one job. If anyone spots a villain
wearing a Sith label, no one gets out
alive. Job done. Can you make it entertaining, though? Please make it about the
characters. Conflict. Drama. Upset. Sacrifice.
Lights. Camera.
Inaction.
Our story opens in
the closing seconds of episode eight. That’s my view. Episode eight is a set-up
for another series. That’s all it could be. So I thought. And it was, when it
arrived. That’s what I found predictable. Not the only problem. But, yes, that.
Never make your
show into a trailer for the next show. That’s liable to get the first show
cancelled, so there is no second show. The main symptom of this diseased error
is a primary story clearly in the captivity of the secondary story you haven’t
told yet. Nor will you tell it, thanks to the symptom of story weakness spread
across your meandering tale.
Part of the problem
is this: I want an hour of STAR WARS
TV so you can develop characters I could care about. But the longest episode is
listed at 49 minutes. Then we knock off the opening titles, recaps, and apocalyptic levels of end credits…
Okay. You made it
shorter. Go for the unexpected bonus. The erosion of screen-time should give us
a slam-bang science fiction serial jam-packed into a half-hour serialised format,
right? Think Flash Gordon or Buck Rogers. Hell, I’d take King of the Rocket Men in a pinch.
Give me chapters
full of Plunging Death, Dangerous
Evidence, High Peril, and throw in a Molten
Menace or a spot of Ten Seconds to
Live for good measure. Republic Pictures would repackage these super-short
efforts into longer features. I’d take Republic Pictures over the Republic
depicted in this STAR WARS TV story,
any day of the week.
Nothing is going to
happen. In the trailer we see a masked figure with a red lightsabre facing a
Lone Jedi Dude. So. There’s your Sith and Jedi problem in the trailer…
If you preserve
even a hint of STAR WARS by staying
true to previous movies set long after this moment in history, if you hope to save
the basic integrity of the overall saga, then as storytellers, as TV writers…
You do so by silencing
those characters who witness the mere existence of the masked figure with the
red lightsabre. Rocks fall. Everyone dies.
STAR WARS never
cared too much about continuity, scientific accuracy, or avoiding holes in the
plot. But we’re talking about a basic bitch chunk of storytelling here. What do
we know about this deep past? Nothing. Surprise us. But to connect it to the
movies, you must deal with this Sith problem if you show Sith waving Sith
weapons around.
You could have done
a story set in the past all about smugglers. No Jedi. And no Sith. Or maybe
hints that some people are Sith. Make it a crime/spy story, in space. Test
loyalty. Pull the rug out from under the characters. No blasters! Well, no.
Loads of blasters. No lightsabres.
Crime/spy story in
space. No Jedi. As far as we know. But ANDOR,
hell that’s been done.
The Sith aren’t
there at all, even if they are there. This is how we roll. Beyond preserving
that, what do you have? Little, unless you stray from the usual Jedi tales. The
stakes, then, are murky.
Keep the hidden existence of the Sith hidden. That’s
it. And so it goes. Phew, that was a close one. After a hell of a high-wire
walk, we did it. Spread over eight episodes. We made it. All the way to the
end. Which is more than a lot of the audience did. We made it. One job.
Success. Until near the end of episode eight and…
For fuck’s sake. You had one job. Over eight episodes.
Ah, the episodes…
They barely pass half an hour of TV each. In
at least one case, we were offered just under half an hour. I checked once.
Once was enough.
So, essentially,
we’re looking at what amounts to four episodes that run for an hour each. And
even looking at that level of the equivalent of two movies, you still ask where
the money went. It didn’t turn up on the TV screen.
Short episodes. And
yet, they drag. There is no unexpected bonus of cramming loads of action into a
brief episode. The opporchancity is frittered away. Instead, there’s this faffery
about hiding the Sith. And little else, beyond the tinny jangling of well-worn
keys.
Keeping the Sith
secret could have worked. Maybe it all worked for you. That’s your business,
not mine. I wish you well. If the focus of the show had been with the Sith from
the start, and the relentless threat of discovery at every turn…then you’d have
had tension.
We’d be on the side
of the Sith as they hide out. Almost uncovered. Maybe uncovered, but they laugh
it off or throw down some ruse. Hell, I’d be up for a Sith sacrifice to
preserve the secret. Would’ve been something.
Darth Carbonara was
awesome. Using those funky moon boots to walk up the walls of the doomed space
station as it fell from orbit, I thought she’d jump to the Jedi ship at the
last second.
But leaping into
space and taking her secret lightsabre with her, burning up in the atmosphere,
was a legendary sacrifice.
Cue twenty YouTube
videos on how Darth Carbonara survived the freefall using her Sith Skillz,
based on the type of lightsabre she wielded and a half-remembered bit of advice
on attuning to your surroundings she picked up from the deathbed of her old
master.
Instead, we had
this series with no content. If you liked the show, you liked the show. Not my
business.
Many
of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.
Spoiler. It was
really sad when Jedi #4 and Jedi #5 died to preserve the integrity of
admittedly shaky STAR WARS lore.
Maybe they were Jedi #5 and Jedi #6. Let’s not trivialise that. Just as sad,
really. Whoever they were.
#TRULYMISSED.
#GONEBUTNOTFORGOTTEN.
#TOTALLYFORGOTTEN.
#IFNOTICEDATALL.
#SADFACE.
#SUPPORTTHECHANNEL.
#BUYMEACOFFEE.
#UTINNI!
Here’s the basic
tale. Jedi are being hunted. The
trailer tells us so. This is a problem with STAR
WARS: dialogue is often indirect. The passive statement tells you the Jedi
are being hunted. An active statement
comes across as dramatic. Someone is
hunting Jedi. Hell, now I am interested in someone hunting these Jedi.
It turns out there
are these two sisters. Identical twins, by the look of them. One grows her hair
longer, we’ll say. She has a cult tattoo, as well. Covered by her longer hair. Cults
feature heavily in the story.
I feel remiss in
not having mentioned Basil the Space Beaver. He’s a merchandising gimmick.
Once upon a time,
on a planet far away, several years ago, there was a cult. That cult was
steeped in the lore of the Dark Side of the Force. This is the magical mystical
religious scientific stuff that gives Jedi and Sith access to mad funky space
powers.
Too lazy to pick up
that coffee cup from across the room? Use the force and levitate the damned
drink to you. Communicate across space using telepathic interplanetary Skype
calls. And so on.
Right now, the
story is about someone who wants revenge against a particular group of Jedi
over an incident that happened sixteen years before. So, in the flashback scenes
I guess we’re 116 years before STAR WARS.
Yikes.
We’ll get there.
Basically, the Jedi turned up years ago and mishandled a mission to recruit two
young girls who were very strong with the Force. One twin sister died. For
reasons of drama and action, we learn both sisters survived.
Cue Darth Vader
muttering about a twin sister. On second thought, nah, forget that.
The “dead” sister
went off to train with a Sith Dude. And the living sister went to train with
the Jedi. It didn’t work out at Jedi HQ. She left the Jedi to become a member
of some kind of galactic repair team. Your spaceship is still under warranty
and she, Osha, turns up to fix the broken thing.
Osha has a cute
robot that’s a merchandising opporchancity.
Someone is going
around flat-out murdering Jedi fools. She looks like Osha. Therefore, she is
Osha. It isn’t long before the Galactic Cops go after Osha. But there must be a
better explanation for this. Surely Osha’s Evil
Twin™ is still alive and she’s the killer…
Come on. That’s too
obvious. Osha must be the killer. Take her in for questioning.
I should introduce
a spoiler for The Matrix…
There’s only one Matrix movie. Thank me later. Second and
third spoons need not apply. There sure as fuck isn’t a fourth one. Spoiler
alert. In The Matrix, Trinity –
actress Carrie-Anne Moss – gets into a bonkers fight right there at the start
of the movie. She’s trapped in a room.
Then she’s off and
running. She is up against supervillainous agents: Men in Black™. Dramatic shit. She hurtles herself across the
rooftops...only to face what looks like certain death.
EXCEPT. That’s part of the plot. To understand
what The Matrix is you really just
have to see it for yourself. Or watch videos online, explaining it, I guess.
Now. Imagine you
want to start THE ACOLYTE on a high.
Carrie-Anne Moss gets herself into this Trinity-style fight. It’s Carrie-Anne
Moss. With a fucking lightsabre. Well,
hell, Jeeves, sign me up to that shit.
And now imagine the
start of The Matrix, but Trinity
doesn’t make it out of the room alive. Bummer. That’s what we are treated to.
And you can hear the committee it took to make this TV show squealing into
their ersatz coffees…
That means, right from the start, no one is
safe.
NO ONE IS SAFE. They tell us that in the
fucking trailer. I know no one is safe. Anyone who catches a glimpse of the
Sith must die. Of all the stories to go with, you went with a severely limiting
tale.
You gave us
Carrie-Anne Moss for a fight knowingly referencing The Matrix, and she dies?
This show cost a fortune. You couldn’t pay her for more than that?! Spoiler
alert for THE ACOLYTE.
There’s a whole
thing about flashbacks. We’ll be seeing more of Carrie-Anne Moss later in the
show and earlier in the timeline. More flashbacks. Too many flashbacks. In one
case the flashback-too-far, what else to call it, serves as an extended recap
of previous episodes for people who have the attention-span of no
attention-span.
We view what should
be a great set-up. Someone is hunting Jedi. So we’ll bring in a character who
follows the trail. The good sister. Osha. Your
sister is hunting Jedi. It’s revenge for how you were all treated sixteen
years ago on that far-off planet with the pretty tree.
There’s a planet
with a pretty tree.
We see subtitles telling us the names of these
planets. Unless you are on an UNKNOWN
WORLD. If it’s an unknown world, how did anyone know to go there, or give
it a subtitle? Well, the world was so unknown that they didn’t know it was an
unknown world: kinda sorta blundered across it. But the subtitle droid stepped
in and plastered letters across the screen.
The planetary subtitles are never explained.
Do they have to be? No. But they are bound to be used in YouTube videos telling
you why every dead character in STAR WARS secretly survived to come back as a
Jedi/Sith or the Bendy Jesuit from the DUNE
movies.
KID VADER: I hate sand.
Osha should be the ideal candidate to lead the team in
search of Mae, her twin sister. Or I should say “twin” sister. Maybe I should
say “twin sister” instead. What would be better than having Osha leading the
charge against evil forces?
Oh, I don’t know.
Maybe skip this storyline and show elements of the Republic going after
smugglers and scoundrels and rascals, and the like. Show that there are evil
factions operating from the shadows, as a precursor to the Empire that’s on the
way. Robot armies. Early clone technology. Space werewolves. Hell, at this
point I’d accept FINDING SPACE NEMO.
STAR WARS is A Disney property. I
thought we’d be in for an identity switch along the lines of FREAKY FRIDAY. Instead, another Disney
production loomed into view: THE PARENT
TRAP.
Fuck, you’d get
more mileage out of TWINS OF EVIL,
and that’s a Hammer movie about identical twins. One’s a vampire. The other
isn’t. Yes, it’s absolute nonsense.
But you’d be better spending your cinematic
time in the company of Jodie Foster on a Friday, Hayley Mills and Hayley Mills
trapping some parents, or the Collinson sisters maybe kinda sorta being evil
twins, as you’d expect from their movie’s title…
The big problem
with THE ACOLYTE is the reluctance of
the twin characters to get involved. If only at least one of them went off on a
damn-fool idealistic crusade…
Your character can
refuse the mission at the start. In the first (fourth) STAR WARS film, Luke Skywalker is interested in the idea of taking
action. But when he’s presented the choice, he turns that offer down. Then the
plot gets in his way and he’s all fired up for adventure. He goes off to the
wars out there in the stars.
But THE ACOLYTE…gives us identical
characters who don’t want to travel the path on offer. Spoiler alert. The good
one is tempted to the bad path and the bad one is tempted to the good path.
You see the obvious
identity-switch coming from light years away. It ain’t no spoiler. There’s a
whole cast of characters, but I’m trying to keep this blog post down in size.
Something below the length of a Space Slug.
Yes, the Jedi are
Space Cops. And they have a Space Cop Cadet along for the ride. She’s all about
restoring public order and arresting people and clapping cuffs on wrists and
taking names.
On the way to
grandmother’s house in the woods, she glimpses a Sith. We’re going to need a
bigger spoiler. I should say something about Obvious Bad Guy. How does that go?
Obvious Bad Guy is Obvious. What do you call a Plot Twist that runs in a
straight line? You don’t call it a fucking Plot Twist, that’s for sure.
And I have to
reference Admiral Ackbar. This fish guy turns up for the defeat of the Empire at
the end of the main saga. When not realising it’s a trap or concentrating all
firepower on that Super Star Destroyer, he’s a pretty chill dude. A late
arrival to the movies, he’s there at the end and that counts for a lot.
Except…the saga
goes on for a few more movies beyond the end. He’s there once more, out of
retirement, I guess, for one last hurrah against a new generation of villains.
Admiral Ackbar dies
so fast that you blink and miss it. His death might as well be off-screen for
all the difference this makes. There then follows a tragic announcement that
he’s gone.
Not dead. Gone. To
the shops, perhaps, for…whatever intergalactic fish guys go shopping for. A
space vape. I dunno. Anyway. To casually dismiss a character in an off-screen
death, or near as damn it, is to Admiral
Ackbar someone.
With this in mind,
I’ll turn to the Wookiee Jedi. Holy flying fuckballs, there’s a Wookiee Jedi.
And the Sith Chippendale is sure to hunt him down. This is going to be fucking
awesome.
Wookiee is hiding
out in the woods, in his fucking element, while the villain closes in, all
Sithed up with no place to go. The clash is going to be absolutely fucking
awesome. You’ll see a Wookiee Jedi go full-on prime-fucking-eval on this Sith
Bastard and you…
You fucking wha?!
Wha?
Seriously. Wha the
fu?
Did the story just…Admiral Ackbar the Wookiee fucking
Jedi?!
What’s the point?
The point is the point of a lightsabre that slashed the Wookiee while he was
sitting in his chair. Outstanding action scene of the decade goes to…well, not
to that fight, obviously. Off-screen bullshit.
There’s a lot of
cape-flapping, key-jangling, lightsabre-ism, and the truly awful
resurrection/reassembly of lines from better STAR WARS products. Ooh, the character said the thing. Wait, saying
the thing in that context is absurd. Don’t worry. Another thing will come along
shortly, and someone will say that.
(No, I am not
touching that fucking abysmal ALIEN
movie, Crapulous, and its recycled
mangled characters and recycled mangled lines. Get away from the franchise, you bitch. I prefer the term artificial sequel, myself.)
Money? I was
stunned to learn the average cost of an episode was almost $29 million dollars.
And I struggle to see where the money went on the television screen. The huge event
in this show is the arrival of the Jedi chorus line in the woods. Need to talk
to that Wookiee. Oh, too late.
Killed off-screen in your chair, watching the Twi’lek formation swimming event
on the Galactic Olympics. Farewell, Wookiee Jedi. You will be remembered. Who
the fuck am I kidding? His name was…
Toast.
Everyone is sad.
Then the Sith Dudebroguy turns up. Masked, of course. He looks like a serial killer
from a slasher movie. Then he sparks up his red lightsabre and the battle is
on.
He’s there to kill all of the Jedi. Any of
these Jedi could remember, from training, that the Sith used to be around back
in the day and they had red lightsabres. So the Sith are back in town. Except,
in the woods.
Which means…
Everyone who fights
in the woods must die. They can’t report to Jedi HQ that the Sith are back in
town, the Sith are back in town. Shout out to Darth Lynott for the musical
reference.
I don’t want to
dwell on the cost of an episode and a bunch of unknown Jedi weaving in and out
of the woods…but they’d have achieved the same effect filming in a park at
night, waving neon tubes around.
One by one, and
sometimes two by two, the Jedi fall to the Sith. And this works. So keep doing
this. Wipe out all those who know. You’ve destroyed any hope of suspense, but,
hey, you have one job in telling this story. Everyone who realises the bad guy
has a red lightsabre…everyone dies.
What about Space
Cop Cadet Blondie? They wouldn’t dare kill off the blonde…if you believe that,
I have a Hitchcock movie to sell you.
After much faffery,
we follow Lone Jedi Dude from the trailer, back on the ship and heading off to
fix things. And the writing comes in and smacks the story up the side of its
fool head. I hate it when the writing comes in and does that to a tale.
Sadly, the
interplanetary telephone isn’t working. It can’t work. Mustn’t work. If a Jedi
survives the slaughter, which he does, then he can’t fly back to HQ or even
phone home like Spielberg’s Extra-Plastic-Terrestrial.
You see how tied to
the concept the whole narrative is. No deviation. Can’t avoid it, swerve,
stumble over, or dodge. The Jedi Team died a fucking death. Leaving this guy to
inevitably go up against the Sith Dude once more…and die in the process...later.
For a whole bunch
of characters set on running away, they spend an awful lot of time stopping in
the middle of a chase. It’s a thing. A whole thing. But I never got around to
the music…
Heavy spoiler. Come
on, you’ve seen clips on the internet. Is there a place for songs in STAR WARS movies or TV shows? Yes. There
are musical numbers. Aliens playing in the cantina band back in episode…four.
And Jabba’s Palace hosts a musical number in episode…six.
Is there a place
for musical numbers in AGATHA ALL ALONG…yes.
That works. It’s riffing off The Wizard
of Oz musical. But the musical bit in this STAR WARS show just reinforced the cult theme. You see, kids, the
Jedi and the Sith are all about recruiting powerful youngsters to their
respective causes. And that narrative paints all sides as horrible.
The grand notion of
a flawed yet benevolent Republic, with its ancient order of magical guardians,
the Jedi, is shot down in flames, painting the Jedi as little more than a step
removed from being child-enslavers. Or worse.
Yep. That’s the
heavy hint in the narrative.
Remember this, if
nothing else. No one killed STAR WARS.
It is still there, on my shelf, ready to watch whenever I feel like it. Even if
Disney takes it off the streaming
service for eternity.
I didn’t make it
past the first episode of that Willow
TV show. And it is gone. Show needed a sense of urgency. More urgent than the
one Disney provided. The original movie shares a lot of midichlorians
DNA with STAR WARS.
Plucky adventurers.
Mad characters. Encroaching evil. Not a Darth Vader character, honest, guv. And
not an Evil Royal behind it all. Madmartigan isn’t Han Solo and he doesn’t fall
in love with the princess who happens to be the daughter of the evil one.
So that’s okay,
then. No, the show wasn’t urgent enough. But to kill it off by removing it from
the streaming service. Now I know who really fired that shot at the start of Bambi.
Spoiler alert for Bambi and Finding Nemo. There will be blood. Anyway, look at that
interesting thing over there…
I don’t want to
take this over ten pages, so let’s skip to the very end. Ultimately, why can’t we all just get along? There are Sith to
fight, that’s why. We reach a point at which all of the Jedi who go up against
the Sith…they are taken care of.
Yes, they went to
live on a nice moisture farm in the country. It’s too far to visit, out there
by the Dune Sea. But Uncle Owen, the farmer, writes regularly to say everything
is going to be okay. We’re all fine here, now, thank you. How are you?
No, I didn’t
mention the Jedi woman with the green skin and the laser-whip. Indiana Jones in Spaaaaaaaaaaaaaace. Turns
out, she whipped the Sith Dudester when he was young, and left scars on his
back. And she puts the whole mystery together like an episode of MURDER SHE WROTE on fucking steroids.
There’s a heavy
reference to shifting the Balance of the Force. We didn’t need that, or the
idea that anyone else could be a pupil of
mine, before he turned to evil. Sure, strip-mine scripts that are set in
the future if it makes your typing sessions easier on the fingers. Understand,
though, that I will hunt down the people who taught you how to read and write.
But the context, mutter-mumble.
Here is the green Jedi, who had an evil pupil thought dead. She discovers that
her pupil is alive. He has to be Sith. So, remember, you have one job. Every
Jedi who learns of the Sith must die, to preserve the fucking story.
Instead, she lives,
and she takes her peculiar problem to the head of the Jedi order…Yoda. We see a
glimpse of Yoda here, and more of Yoda in later historical documentaries.
That’s it, though,
right there. Fucked up beyond all recognition. You did what you set out to do.
Introduce Sith to Jedi for a lively session at the dance in the old barn. And
that would have worked, if you’d killed all the Jedi who were up dancing.
No. You had to go
and do that bit at the end, where the green Jedi goes to reveal all to another
green Jedi. And I have few words left, beyond raw expletives, at this point.
Update. I should’ve
said the Wookiee had a fight in a flashback, but the damage was done. He
couldn’t die in the flashback. Just in the here and now, in a chair, watching
synchronised Twi’leks aim for gold in the Space Olympics.
Oh, and a character
showed up, skulking in a cave. It was Gollum, looking for the One True Ring.
But it fell through the TV cracks into another show that caused J.R.R.
Tolkien’s rotating body to give off a high-pitched whine that fells birds on
the wing to a distance of five miles out.
THE ACOLYTE bows out disgracefully by
plundering a scene from the end of another STAR WARS property, giving us the oddball
hope that setting this show up for a sequel automatically killed off any chance
of making a sequel.
As for finding
faults in ROGUE ONE, here’s a
classic: they had Billie Lourd right there. Should have hired her to dress up
as her mother instead of giving us CGI Carrie Fisher. If you haven’t seen ROGUE ONE, that’s a spoiler. I haven’t
ruined it for you…merely prepared you for that moment.
With the right hair, makeup, and costume,
Billie Lourd would have served as younger stand-in for her mother long enough
to make the scene work. Carrie Fisher looked like Debbie Reynolds and Billie
Lourd resembles both of them. Why head down the Uncanny Valley™ of face replacement for so short a scene?
Luckily, I am not
in charge of making STAR WARS.
Unluckily, it appears no one is. But that’s okay. No one killed STAR WARS. Right there, on my shelf, any
old time I want to watch it. Don’t give in to hate. But, also, you don’t have
to like sub-standard fiction.
Thursday, 4 January 2024
INDIANA JONES AND THE DIAL OF DULLNESS: A REPORT FROM A FUGITIVE.
Finally saw that
movie. And by finally, I mean I don’t
have to watch the entire film again. Just snippets, for the purposes of this
chat.
If you came here to read this, you came here
after watching movies featuring Indiana Jones as the hero. I won’t be
describing every single scene in detail. So if you came here randomly without
having watched any of those stories, you are on stony ground.
There are only three movies about Indiana
Jones. Let’s clear that up from the start. But there are five, and that is
worth mentioning in passing. RAIDERS OF
THE LOST ARK is marketed as INDIANA
JONES AND THE RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK. Indiana goes on to have risky
adventures at THE TEMPLE OF DOOM and
on THE LAST CRUSADE.
After that is anyone’s guess. Spoiler alert.
In the third film, he rides off into the sunset as an adventurous cowboy
should. And that’s that.
Except, belatedly, he allegedly turned up on
the quest for THE CRYSTAL SKULL.
Following those shenanigans in a kingdom, BELATEDLY again, there was something
about a dial of dullness. But with the characters populating that last movie,
it was impossible to care.
No one has ruined Indiana Jones. Those early
movies are still available, after all. Spend your time enjoying what you love,
and turn away from what you hate. If you hate the later films, that is. Maybe
you are just rather blah on them, as
expending hate isn’t worth the effort.
In the
first three films, the road to adventure kicks off with a transition from the
Paramount logo to some sort of depiction of a mountain. There’s a transition to
a mound in the fourth film, which shows the direction we’re heading in, but
they just don’t give a flying fuck by the fifth and very final film in the
series.
Just couldn’t be fucking arsed, could they?
The series is owned by Disney at that point. However, the Paramount logo is
still present and they could have made the standard transition. But no. We get
the sound of ticking. Time is running out for the franchise. We need to push one
more movie out there before the star, Mr Ford, grows too grumpy to alter
digitally.
Indiana Jones heads off on adventures to
stop the Nazis. But not in a fifth film. No. I grabbed hold of that fucking
dial of destiny and went back in time to stop the film being made. And we’re
all better off for that. Occasionally, expending a little hate is worth the
effort. Where did it go wrong?
Too long a gap in production between movie
number three and movie number four. Same again, pretty much, going from movie
four to movie five. The big problem with Indiana Jones was the trio: Lucas,
Spielberg, and Ford. They had to get together to make these movies.
A lot of heels were dragged over film studio
floors to reach where we are now. The movies have dates to go with them: 1981,
1984, and 1989. Then, if we quote Sallah, we cut to 2008 and 2023: bad dates. The initial run covers the
1980s. In the 1990s, there was a TV show.
Spielberg was dragged kicking and screaming
back in for his last hurrah in 2008. The crystal skull beckoned. Ford was happy
to make a fifth one as long as the gap in production wasn’t anything like the
gap between the third and the fourth one. Bad
dates.
Lucas could have directed one. As long as he
had his STAR WARS collaborators
Harrison Ford and composer John Williams on board, no reason why not. Lucas
reminds me of Sergio Leone – both being directors with great influence on the
world of movies. They directed around a handful each. Spielberg keeps churning
them out by way of comparison, chasing the output of Alfred Hitchcock.
Indiana
Jones. We always knew that one day you’d digitally walk back through cinema’s
door.
The first film featured great stunt work. This
is true of the trilogy. Then the production gap kicked in and computer
generated images were available for use in the fourth film. Too available. A
lot of people say that the fourth film lost them when Indiana Jones dodged the
effects of a nuclear blast by shielding himself inside a refrigerator.
Not me. No. For some reason, I expected that level of nonsense from a
story featuring Indiana. It was Tarzan in the jungle, later. The whole foliage-bedecked
sequence. I’m sure on paper that a duel in the jungle, across vehicles, with
swash being buckled…
Yes, I’m certain that looked fun on paper.
But on the computerised side of things…
Fuck off. I mean…this is the crystal skull
adventure. Misadventure. Fight scenes and chase sequences really show their
lack of value and are revealed as padding in this fourth film. I haven’t
reached the tedium of the mystical dial, yet. That’s a whole movie and many
years away at that point.
There are physical stunts in THE CRYSTAL SKULL. But there weren’t
meant to be that many computerised effects. The opportunity slipped out from
under them. Was the fridge a step too far?
When Indy went to the doom-laden temple,
that sequel/prequel had to go above and beyond, didn’t it? Did it? It didn’t
have to. More of the same would have done us, I’m sure. Had that been the case,
would we have complained about over-familiarity, though?
The opening of the first film is great fun.
It gives us Jones the adventurer. He hates snakes. And we meet his enemy.
Belloq. More on him, during the fifth film. Shortly after that, we see Jones the academic.
His friend Marcus Brody hands him a mission. It’s important that you understand
the pacing of the first film. There’s the mission before the mission which
somehow ties in to the mission – a set-up freely borrowed from the movies of Bond
– James Bond.
Action in the jungle. Meet Belloq. Return to
academia. Encounter Belloq later. Yes, we’ll keep returning to Belloq. But
remember this: SHORTLY after Belloq, we see Jones the academic. The short
opening sequence sets the standard for the entire movie’s pace. Shame that
wasn’t the case for the whole series.
What about those opening sequences? In the
first movie, Jones is in the field facing action. He encounters a villain he’s
met before, and he’ll meet that villain again. Escaping off in a plane, we
travel with Doctor Jones to the groves of academe. He’s Professor Jones again
within the first quarter of an hour of the film’s opening.
In the second movie, he’s in the field. This
is a bit different. The opening gives us villains, but throws them away.
Really, the sequence introduces us to Indiana’s sidekicks. Still, he makes an
escape by plane just barely within the first fifteen minutes. Then it is on to
other adventures.
The third movie opens with a flashback. But
it does relate to the later plot. We’re out of the flashback and back at the
university just barely within the first fifteen minutes of the start.
Then we have this gap in production. In the
fourth movie, we start very directly with the villains. But we don’t return to
academia until almost 25 minutes after the movie starts. This is true of the
fifth film. We have a flashback, introducing the villain. And it is almost 25
minutes before we hit academia.
So, just looking at these stretches of time,
over time, the sweet spot for an opening is close to ten minutes. But we’ll
allow for slight detours and go up to almost a quarter of an hour. The last two
films take this too far. For a lot of people, that fifth film gives them the
big highlight of the movie in the opening flashback. That wore off for me
pretty quickly. It could have been cut in half, reducing the number of digital
shots related to a Nazi train.
Do I object to the absurdity of it all? No.
The movies are full of improbable nonsense. We demand that, after a little
while. Escapist fantasy is escapist. The only place to draw the line is at
heavily foreshadowed plot points that lumber into view with all the subtlety of
no subtlety. Watch the fifth movie and see. See what I did there.
Escapism. The second movie, set rather
puzzlingly before the first film, opens in a nefarious nightclub. You might say
it’s a wretched hive of scum and villainy. The action becomes more and more
improbable as the seconds pass. Escaping to an aeroplane and from the aeroplane
is as daft a sequence as being saved in a refrigerator is, come the fourth film.
No parachutes. Just an inflatable yellow
raft. It falls improbably to a landing on snow. This is a Slalom on Mount Humol, going by the soundtrack. Yes, I am playing
the music of John Williams as I type.
The raft goes even further into the realms
of improbability, leading to a river. Absolute nonsense, and every bit as daft
as the refrigerator scene from the fourth movie. Let’s detour into that for a
second.
Indiana Jones survives a nuclear blast
inside a fridge. Any radiation damage he suffers is offset by his experience
with the Holy Grail from the third film. We’ll run with that. If you hate the
refrigerator and nuclear bomb double-act, take note: you’d have fucking
detested it in BACK TO THE FUTURE,
where it was slated to appear originally. Spielberg’s a nut on the subject.
Fortunately, Doctor Jones survives the
nuclear blast and is warned by the military – don’t climb into fridges. They
aren’t safe. That’s for any children watching. I think nuclear weapons are a
wee bit more dangerous than fridges are. That’s for any adults reading.
What
stands out in the first film? Many things. The truck chase. Not just the truck
chase…
From the moment Indy and Marion start their
escape from the tomb, the action is terrific. It doesn’t feel padded. The movie
comes in at under two hours, even including closing credits. Okay. What stands
out in the second film?
The movie is a rollercoaster ride. Yes,
literally. The mine cart chase is a theme park ride waiting to happen. But
there’s more to the film than that. Willie Scott and Short Round are based on
characters from old movies. I say they are great at conveying the mood. You
might find them irritating.
A fish-out-of-water nightclub singer and a
gambling kid sidekick are just right for this second (first) story. They all
visit the temple, take in the sights, see a spot of doom, and have spooky
adventures.
I suppose the second film is set before the
first film to keep the hope alive that Indy would still be with Marion in a
third movie. Maybe that was the plan at the time, but it didn’t pan out.
Technically, I should watch TEMPLE OF
DOOM first in the series, but I can’t be bothered. Maybe one day. We’ll
have a detour into Sergio Leone in a wee while.
What stands out in the third film? The tank
chase. But there’s more to it than that. Marcus Brody is in the field, for
once. And the last crusade they are all on…it’s just a great way to end a
trilogy. This wannabe Bond movie has a James Bond actor in it, after all.
So what stands out in the first three films?
We are given characters to root for in dire situations. Those situations
include a truck chase, a mine chase, and a tank chase. But without the
characters, you would have padding and nothing but padding. We are also given
characters that hark back to the days of Old Hollywood.
Indiana Jones raids that lost ark, and, to do
so, he’s borrowed items of clothing from Charlton Heston in a film called Secret of the Incas. If you are
wondering why no one sued, well, it was a Paramount picture. Keep it in the
company and all is well.
Before he reaches the doomed temple, Indiana
appears to be taking style tips from Humphrey Bogart in Casablanca. And his
(supposedly) last crusade is a Bond film with a Nazi coat of paint on it. (A
pot Ian Fleming himself dipped into, in the novel Moonraker.)
Characters we care about. Indy and Marion.
The characters not everyone roots for in that doomed temple: Willie Scott and
Short Round. But you need to be heartless not to care about Short Round
desperately trying to turn Indy away from the cause of evil. There is
heartlessness in that movie. And it is done practically, rather than digitally.
Willie Scott is a hapless force of nature.
And even if you don’t buy into it, hey, surely you still care about Indy in
that second film. The point in this prequel is that Willie Scott is definitely
not Marion.
We
could’ve been given more of the same, more of the stuff that appeared on the
big screen in the first movie. But the temple is full of doom, and it is very
bleak in places. Call it an experiment in giving you more Indiana, but in a
different setting with new sidekicks and a departure from the widely
globetrotting first movie.
It’s pretty much about the palace above the
temple, some nods to the cinema of Sir David Lean, the temple, and that literal
rollercoaster ride. The movie is a little longer than Indy’s first cinematic
outing. But not overlong. We’ll get to that bit.
I like the combination of Willie Scott and
Short Round. Yes, they are plunged into horror. There’s an old-fashioned
movie-making sensibility at work, at the same time delivering a film that puts
the gore on screen rather than in the shadows…though shadows always play a part
in stories featuring Doctor Jones.
Characters we care about. For the last ride
into the sunset, we’re joined by Marcus Brody who provides a fair bit of
comedy. Sallah makes a brief but welcome return. Connery clucks his way through
the production declaring that everything is intolerable. But the movie is
highly tolerable.
For once, the love-interest is a villain.
That’s hardly a spoiler. Obvious villains are obvious, and I’ve refrained from
naming another obvious villain here. Still wouldn’t be a spoiler if I said the
name. The movie doesn’t outstay its welcome. And the series doesn’t outstay its
welcome, either. Near the end of the film, Spielberg is dangling over a cleft
in the planet. The audience is there, holding him up. Spielberg reaches for
another movie in the series…
Spielbergiana…let it go.
Let us turn to the cinematic masterpiece
that is INDIANA JONES AND THE KINGDOM OF
THE CRYSTAL SKULL. In light of the fifth movie, we can dub the fourth movie
with this title: cinematic fucking
masterpiece. Which version, though? Frank Darabont surfaced to kick the
script around. He had form, having worked on the TV version of Indy’s
adventures. But there were a lot of cooks in that kitchen. Hardly any are
credited officially.
Darabont isn’t credited in the opening. There
are characters in the movie that weren’t in Darabont’s head or the script that
fell out of his head. How much of his input made it to the finished production?
Hard to say. Darabont was caught between Spielberg and Lucas. A rock and an
even harder rock.
When these new characters turn up after an
agonising pre-production period, they feel bolted on. I knew none of the script
chicanery when I watched the movie. Is it a cinematic masterpiece?
No.
Is it a bad movie? The first hour of the
film is pretty much what you’d expect from a film featuring Indiana Jones if
the actor hadn’t portrayed Indy in a movie in a long time. Nostalgia played a
huge factor in the movie’s financial success. Also, Ford still had it, had it
in spades, diamonds, clubs, and hearts, when he made the film. Spielberg didn’t
really come across as a director who wanted to be there. But Ford was game. He
made sure he was fit for the assignment.
Ray Winstone has very little to do as Mac, a
friend of Indy’s from the war years. He turns up a heartbeat before Indiana
does, and then rapidly betrays Indy. So much for that so-called friendship.
It’s hard to care when the instant character goes for instant betrayal.
Indiana is built for instant characters. He
meets Belloq. Someone he’s met before. For us, that’s our introduction to the
villain. Indiana talks to Marcus, an academic colleague of long acquaintance.
Indy meets Sallah, an old friend who guides Indy through the problems with the
search for the lost ark. All instant characters. So much for the first film.
Mac as a friend who betrays Indy in the opening scene of the fourth movie…just
doesn’t cut it. And there’s no recovery from that, which is why Mac has very
little to do thereafter.
Cate Blanchett also has very little to do.
She arrives on the scene as Irina Spalko – she’s a budget Rosa Klebb from a far
better Bond movie, reminding us that the character is a budget Rosa Klebb from
a far better Bond movie, and that she has very little to do.
Igor Jijikine is the henchman. But, y’know,
if they’d ditched Mac and Irina and beefed this guy’s role up and given him a
memorable sub-henchman of his own, I think the movie would have played better.
Jim Broadbent is okay, but he has the
unenviable task of being a replacement character for Denholm Elliott while he
walks past a portrait of Denholm as Marcus Brody. Broadbent is given a little
more to do than that, but not much. I’d say he fares pretty well out of the
experience. Denholm also puts in a cameo as a statue at the faculty.
I’m not really a fan of Shia LaBeouf, but he
does what’s asked of him and he’s okay. Except for the jungle sequence. Not his
fault. He turns up in this film as Marlon Brando. No, seriously. If you missed
the reference, that’s what was going on there.
John Hurt was, presumably, well-paid for his
appearance. I have the sense that he’s a soft replacement for Connery. Connery
was to have had a cameo, but that didn’t suit Sean. If his role had been
enlarged, he could have been off in the jungle, driven mad, and had a few key
scenes.
How to fit Sean in? At the wedding. That was
the plan, I guess. We’ll return to the wedding.
Crystal skulls abound in this story. The
year is 1957, and the movie opens to Elvis singing for the entertainment of the
people who had the most fun making this film. I’m talking about the American Graffiti rejects racing against
the villains. The youngsters soon depart.
Indy still has it. The Nazis are no longer
suitable as villains. (That would change.) Hitler is out. Commies are in. Hell,
they could have at least hinted that they’d saved Hitler’s brain.
Lucas dragged the Roswell incident into
proceedings from the 1940s, and here are the Russians looking to loot something
crystalline and skullish from a top secret warehouse. They’d have been better
off going after the ark…glimpsed in a throwaway joke.
This opening sequence is long. Far too long.
Reduce the characters. Cut the time spent on the opening. Leaving aside CRUSADE, as Indy is right there as
River Phoenix in the flashback, CRYSTAL
SKULL takes the longest of all five movies to show Indy as a character on
the screen. Hell, that’s allowing for TEMPLE
OF DOOM, which runs a whole musical number before he walks into the club.
After a bumpy start, and clunky
introductions of various characters, Indy is on the hunt for an old colleague:
Oxley. This is John Hurt, who babbles throughout his performance, and then
returns to sanity to babble an explanation involving creatures that are
definitely not aliens.
If
they were aliens, that would hurt Spielberg’s feelings, as he didn’t want to be
heavily associated with making movies about aliens. Says Spielberg, signing up
to direct a fourth movie about Indiana Jones. Could we make the movie about a
shark skull, maybe? One of crystal. No one would notice.
Let’s deal with the mutt. Or Mutt. Shia is
playing Marlon Brando by way of James Dean, filtered through the coffee-paper
of American Graffiti. But the
character is named…after a dog. See what they did there…
There’s a motorbike chase. I quite like that
chase. It’s a bit of fun. Musically, it’s enjoyable. Leading up to the chase,
we discover Mutt’s mother’s name isn’t Martha. That would be too much of a
coincidence. No, her name is Marion. This had to be the worst-kept secret in
moviedom: Karen Allen would reprise her role as Marion Ravenwood.
Why be so coy about this inside the movie,
when the actress was on the poster and in the trailers? Oh, and credited in the
opening. This was 2008, and the internet was a thing in a way that it hadn’t
been in (checks notes) 1989. There weren’t even a million users of the
primitive internet back in ’89.
Reminds me of STAR TREK: INTO DIMNESS. A movie that went out of its way, in 2013,
to hide the fact that it was THE WRATH OF
KHAN remade. In 2013. With the internet. And phones. A worldwide squeal of
internet annoyance over the phones and your secret is busted. What was all that
shit with this John Harrison guy? In the non-build-up to this non-film, he’s definitely not Khan. Spoiler alert.
No one cared.
Excuse me while I veer off into talk of the
Keaton-Jackman Effect. In 1989, irate Bat-fans physically wrote letters to
complain about Michael Keaton’s casting as the lead character in Tim Burton’s BATMAN movie. The news that a sequel was
announced off the back of the film’s success led to fans commenting that Keaton
better be fucking involved, or there’d be no point watching the damned thing.
This happened later with the character of
Wolverine. Who the fuck is Hugh Jackman?
Keaton had a dozen movie credits to his name and was derided as being a comedy
actor with no business portraying Bruce Wayne, let alone the Batman. Jackman
had two movies behind him and was slagged for not having a career yet.
Presumably, if Jackman were the veteran of
ten Australian comedies he’d have been wrong, so wrong, for Wolverine on that
basis. After the release of X-Men,
fans demanded a solo outing for Wolverine and that only Hugh Jackman could play
him.
We’ll call this the Keaton-Jackman Effect.
One of the best portrayals of the character
by Jackman is in the movie Logan,
directed by James Mangold. I’ll return to him on the small matter of a dial. Of
dullness.
Things that don’t often work. Belated
sequels to movies. Sequels so delayed that you are in another decade, or, gasp,
a different century. Bringing back a much-loved character in a cameo role so
that the torch can be passed down to the next generation. I think that worked
once, in a STAR TREK TV show. In
movies, not so much.
I
haven’t bothered to explain the plotting of these movies featuring Indiana
Jones. Maybe I should summarise. Indy is an archaeology professor who would
give real archaeology professors absolute fucking nightmares. In his first
outing, he tries to stop the Nazis from claiming a powerful pile of dust made
from rocks. This is before war breaks out.
Stop the bad guys from obtaining the
mystical thing. Have adventures along the way. That’s the formula.
A word or two about William Hootkins. Hootkins
is in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, taking
a lesson in biblical matters from Harrison Ford. Indy sketches out a staff and
explains what the Ark of the Covenant actually is.
Mr Hootkins is also remembered as Porkins in
STAR WARS. Porkins is the recipient
of the worst advice in a space movie. As he struggles to deal with some trouble
aboard his one-man fighter jet, er, spaceship, while attacking dams in the
Ruhr Valley the DEATH STAR, Hootkins is told to…EJECT.
WHERE TO?!
Oh, to the surface of the DEATH STAR, which
Luke Skywalker will shortly demolish? That’s assuming there’s even an
atmosphere on the DEATH STAR’S surface. I quibble over these things. Where are
the clouds on the DEATH STAR, damn it?!
To this day, I think all the lights on the
DEATH STAR should flicker as the big ray gun is fired. A man in an orange
jumpsuit sticks his head through prison bars and intones…dead planet walking. Yes, I’ve seen too many prison movies. Frank
Darabont appears to be responsible for many of them.
Why mention Hootkins in connection with
Indiana Jones? CRYSTAL SKULL retreads
that government guy moment in the hunt for a few nostalgia fumes. Jones is
dumped by the Russians at the top secret warehouse. We’re introduced to the
idea of aliens.
They are extradimensional lifeforms, damn
it!
Jones is betrayed by Mac and escapes.
Harrison Ford does his own stunts here. The safety wires are easy enough to
remove digitally, and I have no problem with that. For some reason, there’s an
experimental rocket sled that leads off in the direction of nowhere. Indy
hitches a lift.
In the morning, he reaches a deserted town.
It is a nuclear test site. Let’s find out how American houses stand up to those
atoms. Indy takes shelter in a fridge. The Russians race out of town in their car
and die in a haze of sub-par digital destruction.
Indy is discovered, decontaminated, and then
interrogated by government guys. This section reminded me of Hootkins.
Essentially, the scene goes nowhere. Then it’s off to academia. Is Indy a
communist agent? The only enemy agent he consorted with was a suspect Austrian
that time in Venice. And she could hardly be described as communistical. Ah, Venice. It’s okay. You get a pass
for dallying with the Nazis, provided they are rocket scientists.
Leaving the fourth movie under something of
a cloud, Professor Jones boards a train. To emphasise that he is older, his hat
has turned grey for a bit. Enter Marlon Brando and a spot of exposition leading
to the motorbike chase.
There’s some faffing around with a language
Indy must work hard to understand. Being a movie, this takes a few seconds. He
and Mutt are off in search of Professor Oxley. And possibly treasure, power,
fortune and glory…
There’s a bit of Indy stuff leading to the
next location and the next location. This is all okay. Ultimately, once you’ve
pieced so many clues together it is time for capture. Indy and Mutt are
captured and taken into the commie camp of captured characters.
John Hurt earns more money for babbling a
bit. Karen Allen puts in a welcome return as Marion. We get some character
stuff. And the repeat, I guess, of a thing no one wants to see. But there it
is. And we’ll see more of it in the future.
Two characters get together in a movie. The
audience cheers. Damn. What to do in the rest of the series? I know. We can
split them up so we can put them back together again. Now, in defence of Marion
as a character…that’s how she starts.
Indiana Jones walks back through her door in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK. She’s an instant character from his past.
They were together. And they split. Now he
needs her help, and she joins his world of adventure. Marion vanishes from the
other movies. It’s in the fourth film that she returns after a long absence
which…
Allows these characters to get back together
again. Oh, and here’s your son.
Marion is used as a hostage to force Indy’s hand. Indy, slow on the uptake,
realises Marion Ravenwood is Mutt’s mother. He lags a bit behind on the rest of
that story.
Mutt takes the lead and mounts an escape
that goes nowhere. Except, we all officially learn that Mutt is Indy’s son.
Next, we shift into the jungle in daylight and a convoy of vehicles. And this
is where the movie loses me.
So, instead, for a bit, I’ll talk about STAR WARS. George Lucas, again. Once
upon a time, in an earlier galaxy that just happens to be this one, STAR WARS was STAR WARS. As soon as you number them, and start at the number four, you’ve created scope for filming
the first three.
What then? Announce episodes seven, eight,
and nine?
When episode seven was announced, I believed
four things. One. Harrison Ford would get his long-time wish and Han Solo would
die. Two. Luke Skywalker would merge with the Force and become a ghost. Three.
We would see Princess Leia use the Force in a big way. Four. They could do what
they liked with the story, as long as they didn’t just repeat the attack on the
DEATH STAR.
It is the year 2015. Harrison Ford plays a
character who had a happy ending with his Princess. Now, we find that they’ve
split up over the thorny issue of their wayward son. Also, Luke Skywalker has
fucked off somewhere.
Much time has passed. Format? The original
characters would appear, and pass the mantle of heroism to the next generation
of new and interesting characters. But the original characters would still be
involved in a major way. Up until Han Solo’s death, of course.
Implementation? Utterly sideline the
characters we turned up to see. Not how I’d have written it. You want to keep
the fans happy, right? Start with the regulars from the very opening and add
the fresh cast from that point on. You don’t utterly sideline people. In the
much-delayed and frankly unwanted BLADE
RUNNER sequel, you would like to think you could add a layer of interest to
what was great before.
You’ve done a man’s job, sir. I guess you’re through, huh?
The writing is certainly through. If you
must bring Gaff back in a sequel, meet him in a bar watching a dancer perform
with a neon snake. Don’t stick him in a nursing home.
TONY SOPRANO: It’s a retirement community!
When there’s talk of retirement in BLADE RUNNER,
it doesn’t mean taking it easy. No, it means taking it rather fucking harshly.
Funny, that. Harrison Ford, again. Almost as if there’s a fucking pattern here.
He had a happy ending with his replicant girlfriend in the first movie, and
that went to shit in the sequel. Is this the default setting for films, now?
Where was I? Just make what worked part of
your plan. And do stuff with it. Don’t sideline it, remove it utterly,
diminish, belittle, or berate it. We’re going to need the Roman numerals for
this one.
Episode VII. THE FORCE
AWAKENS.
Before the meeting can take place, they find themselves surrounded by
space pirates on the Blood Red Moon of Bantonnay.
This is no chance encounter, but an ambush arranged by sinister forces
hoping to overthrow the Republic and bring about the return of THE GALACTIC
EMPIRE.
Now, Ben Solo, Jedi Knight, and his smuggler father Han race across the
galaxy aboard the Millennium Falcon, with the mighty Chewbacca, to haul Luke Skywalker’s
feet from the flames one more time….
It’s better to
start with Ben as a good guy and then be tempted by the Dark Side. We would
care, then. Also, Han would never admit to hauling Leia’s feet from the
flames…but he’d gloat a bit over Luke, just for the nostalgia value. Han would
also call Leia sister as a joke.
As a Senator, Leia could reasonably sneak
away from politics for a time. The New Republic is still rough around the
edges, and Han smuggles supplies to good causes when bureaucracy stands in the
way of decency.
Those new characters come in to create
factions. You’d look for at least three factions of good guys, duelling and
blasting their way across the end of the movie in typical STAR WARS style. Drop a bunch of Darths in there for innovative
duels, and you are all set.
ANYWAY. This shit about the characters
getting together only to be split apart by the next movie just to get back
together again…is really fucking annoying. But we haven’t talked about the
mummified corpse in the room.
The
Mummy, from 1999, may give you that Indy fix for the ’90s. Its roots lie in
the movie by Karl Freund, so maybe you are getting that Indy fix for the ’30s.
There’s a game cast, sand, action and humour aplenty…
And a couple who get together in this movie
only to stay together, married, with a kid sidekick in the sequel. Well, isn’t
that something? Okay, the actual mummy has a fucking tragic love-life, but come
on – he’s the villain.
Back to the CRYSTAL SKULL. It’s definitely not alien. The shape of it nods in
the direction of H.R. Giger and Ridley Scott, but we’ll gloss over that. Truck
convoy. Indiana Jones. Marion is with him. Hell, her theme is playing in the
background.
And then. We have a clunky combination of
live stuff blended, in a blender, with the computer mulch. Where’s Vic
Armstrong when you need him? Well, he was fucking available when he was fucking
available, but you took too long to make this one so he wasn’t available for
any stunt coordination on this one.
Yes, Vic Armstrong is listed in the crew for
that third Mummy movie that kept him
away from Indiana Jones, but, as we all know, there is no third Mummy movie. Spielberg had the annoying
habit of shooting down ideas based on films that were just released, but
another four years would go by before any meaningful progress. It’s so tedious.
They would lose actors from these lumbering projects and just have to make do
later.
Still waiting for Even More American Graffiti. Maybe Harrison Ford could come back
and sink that franchise as well, completing the fucking run and scoring bonus
points for shits and giggles.
The jungle sequence is green, plastic, and
cheese-laden. However, the music performs far more valiantly at this point in
the movie than the on-screen action does. John Williams turns up for the job,
no matter the failings in this chase.
I am not here to root for the music in the
chase, though. Music may compensate for certain technical deficiencies. If your
rubber shark is broken, just show underwater sequences set to music and let the
editing help you through.
But the jungle chase sets the tone and mood
for the declining half of this film. Long before we reach the scenes with the
ants, we must contend with the business of the monkeys. Monkey business? Spielberg
should have hired the Marx Brothers.
Mutt is left behind in the jungle. He
catches up by heading everyone off at the pass. This involves the use of vines.
When Chewbacca impersonates Tarzan in the STAR
WARS universe, it’s brief and that makes it funny.
And then there’s this shit. Not Shia’s
fault. Even when Mutt heads everyone off at the pass, he still sees them far
ahead. So he has to head them off at the pass all over again. Woeful pacing. It all ends in tears, except that it
all ends in ants.
Computer generated ants. I don’t even know where to start with this. In
other movies, there’d be snakes. Or a lion. Here we’ve reached the point at
which computers are capable of generating swarms of ants. True, The Mummy movie gave us swarms of insta-killer
beetles. Not the best part of that movie. Never mind all that.
We’re in a race to reach the place. The
refrigerator sequence is on the same level of absurdity as the waterfall
sequence that follows the ant sequence. All that matters is reaching this lost
kingdom with crystal skulls in it.
Get there before the commies do. Is this
important? Let the commies brave all of the tricks and traps first and then mop
up after. But no, we’ll have our heroes do all the work for the villains this
time around.
I’m not sure about the guardians of this
lost place. Either…they crawl along tunnels to reach thin walls that they burst
out of…or they are imprisoned in the walls. You know, maybe they live in the
spaces between dimensions, courtesy all that alien technology. It isn’t alien.
No. It’s from somewhere…don’t know.
Basically, all you have to do is open the
doorway using the crystal skull. Then you reach the control room of the alien
spaceship. It’s from another dimension, damn it. And the movie delivers on a
mystical ending.
By that point we’ve had Indy declare that
this is intolerable, in a nod to an earlier movie. He also spouts the line
about a bad feeling that you’ll find
repeated over in STAR WARS. So who
cares if an Indy movie gives you another mystical ending to a movie with Indy
in it.
It is an ending that seems pretty harsh on
everyone who lived in the immediate area, protecting the immediate area, but
the movie glosses over that one. Rosa Klebb’s stand-in seeks the knowledge that
is too much for Indy and friends.
They
escape from CGI hell, and we head off to the wedding. Ah, the wedding. As
originally scripted, I guess Henry Jones Senior and Sallah were to be
bridesmaids or something and that pleased neither actor.
The hat passes from Indiana to Mutt
and…Indiana promptly takes it back. Everyone lives happily ever…there’s another
belated sequel. Well, fuck. On the bonus side, this movie comes in at just
under two hours and then they roll credits.
Half of the film is worth watching. The
first half leads you to believe that you are having adventures with geriatric
Indiana Jones. Not true. That’s for the sequel. A sequel not directed by
Spielberg and with no story input by George Lucas.
I’d likened Sergio Leone to George Lucas.
What’s the right order in which to watch these films? You could watch TEMPLE OF DOOM, RAIDERS, and LAST CRUSADE in that order just to keep
the dates right. Chances are, you are just fine watching RAIDERS first.
You could view The Good, the Bad and the Ugly before A Fistful of Dollars and For
a Few Dollars More. Try it. You’d be watching a film set during the
American Civil War and then two films set after. Leone makes this quite clear
by having the Clint Eastwood character do something very obvious at the end of The Good, the Bad and the Ugly to tie
the other movies into a later timeline.
There are dates on gravestones that also
confirm this. But you can’t totally trust time in a Sergio Leone movie. His use
of guns from crazy time periods is quite deliberate, as he evokes an atmosphere
related to events beyond the Wild West. That’s how you can spot the MG 42 in A Fistful of Dynamite, even though the
gun wasn’t invented at the time. Leone liked to draw the viewer’s attention to
other wars, other massacres, and other revolutions in that film.
We’re glossing over Indiana Jones attempting
to blow up the lost ark with an unbuilt Russian weapon in RAIDERS. That brings me back to Belloq, in the end. In the end,
there’s a fifth Indy movie. The DIAL OF
DESTINY. My soul is prepared. How’s yours?
Do you want to know the plot? It’s right
there in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK.
Belloq explains it to Indiana Jones. And the makers of the DIAL OF DULLNESS were listening. You can see the director, James
Mangold, having the spark of an idea appear above his furrowed brow.
Look
at this. It’s worthless. Ten dollars from a vendor in the street. But I take
it, and bury it in the sand for a thousand years: it becomes priceless.
Belloq is talking about a watch. And that is
pretty much the plot. I’ve written at length about this movie without writing
about this movie. Length. Yes. It overstays its welcome, running well beyond
two hours.
Part of the blame lies with the extended
opening flashback to the war. An orc steps in from The Lord of the Rings to tell us the good news. Looks like Nazis are back on the menu, boys.
Indy is hunting for a mystical object. Forget all that. It is nonsense of the
worst kind. There’s a fake mystical object. But there’s a much better real
mystical object. And…
Why the fuck are you dithering over this
multiple choice essay on which magic item the hero is after? Pick one and stick
with it.
Of all the people involved in the movie, the
actor who appears to be having the most fun is Toby Jones in the flashback.
What to say of Indiana Jones and the
Rubberised face of Youth…
Harrison Ford’s face is de-aged for the
movie. But not his voice. He’s too grumpy to alter digitally. Isn’t it great to
see younger Indy battling Nazis again? If they’d treated it as a James Bond
franchise and made one every few years, we’d have had movies set during the
war.
Would a full series have deflated and
diluted the action? Eventually, any series tires out. I think I’d have
preferred that to the fits and starts and sputterings of the way it all went.
Am I going to explain this last movie to you?
Too much CGI. Overlong movie. Ke Huy Quan
should have come back in for the fifth film. Short Round would have handled the
fight scenes, protecting Doctor Jones. This is the cry that went up. But he was
better off out of it, I guess.
The Nazi American Eagle has landed on
the moon. It is the year 1969 and Doctor Jones is living in some sort of
twilight existence, teaching disinterested students who would have been born
after the war. Yes, bored feckless Baby Boomers. That’s the people he’s
teaching in the seconds leading up to his retirement.
TONY SOPRANO: It’s a retirement community!
Indy is saddled with a trouble-prone force
of nature who is also an instant character from his past. There’s a kid
sidekick who almost knows how to fly. This will be important later. In a
lumbering way.
We could care, but the movie doesn’t go out
of its way to help us in that direction. Disposable characters are murdered by
disposable thugs. The chief villain of the piece would appear to be the writer.
But we’ll settle for a budget version of Wernher von Braun in the form of a
Bond villain who was a better Bond villain when he was in a real Bond movie.
It’s not Mads Mikkelsen’s fault that he has
this unerring ability to locate Indiana Jones. The chief villain is the writer,
remember. The plot concerns a dial, or half of it. And an item that can locate
the other half of it.
So there’s…
I am rapidly losing the will to type. That
fucking digital train sequence at the start. Go and watch The First Great Train Robbery. That’s really Connery on top of that
train. The train is real, too. It’s too much to ask Harrison to do that at his
age. I get that. But does so much of the train sequence need to be faked?
Anyway. Nazi flashback. Cut to 1969. There’s
a lousy set-up that cannot possible pay off. Indy, in his apartment, puts a
fridge magnet over the photo of Marion. Yes, you guessed it. They photocopied
the STAR WARS thing and shoved it here.
Just a reminder, for you…
Harrison Ford plays a character who had a
happy ending with his Princess wife. Now, we find that they’ve split up
over the thorny issue of their wayward son. Also, Lucas Spielberger has fucked
off somewhere.
The thorny issue of the wayward son, in this
case, is the off-screen death of Mutt. Did they? Wait. Did they just Admiral Ackbar the motherfucker? Foul
set-up: Indy and Marion are no longer together AGAIN.
Payoff? There isn’t one. They get back
together at the end of the movie. That’s the plan. It lumbers into view the
moment Indy pulls the fridge move. He’d have been as well climbing inside it
and waiting for another nuke.
If the set-up is lousy, I couldn’t care less
about the resolution. An older Short Round or Mutt could have been here to
handle the fights. And the quips. No level of nostalgia could save this
overlong movie.
Various villains cycle through and there are
chases, I’m sure. Basil Shaw and his daughter Helena could have been so much
more in this film. Sadly, not the case. Basil was obsessed with the dial, in
much the same way as Henry Senior was fixated with the Holy Grail.
This obsession has passed down to Basil’s daughter
who is also Indy’s goddaughter, Helena Shaw. But it isn’t enough for this
movie. After faffing about chasing around New York on a horse, Indy…that was
his stunt double with a computerised face…I started to suspect that Ford just
standing and sitting down might be computerised as well. Where were we?
Indy is on the trail. The Nazis are on the
trail. Helena is on her way, one step ahead of everyone else. There is a nice
flashback to more of Toby Jones and a younger actress playing Helena. And there
is a great shot of both Helena actresses as the older one remembers the past by
staring at her younger reflection fading from an aeroplane window.
If the movie had the promise of that one
scene, damn it.
This was the first thing I’d seen Phoebe
Waller-Bridge in, though I’d heard her in the movie about young Han Solo. The
promise of the characterisation was there in that aeroplane scene. She is
playing to a movie type. The troubled character who gets into scrapes, and who,
at some point, breaks through into a sheen of positivity that lasts for the
rest of the film.
I’m not defying anyone to play that part and
overcome the script problems. Close, though. Phoebe was given stuff to do, but
not enough of it and not enough of the right things for a movie about Indy and
his supporting cast.
It isn’t enough to think that the first half
of the CRYSTAL SKULL is a movie about
Indy doing Indy stuff. If the second half of the movie slides down the shitter,
the overall movie dies. I feel that this is the case with people who frothingly
tell me that the first half of Full Metal
Jacket is great and this news alone makes it a great movie.
Hmmm.
DIAL
OF DULLNESS. What is the plot? Just watch. Or. It’s just about a watch. It
is not really watchable. Helena Shaw is there to pull a heel-turn in reverse
and finally endear herself to the audience. Well, the end credits rolled…and I
am still waiting for that bit.
Indiana should have recognised his
goddaughter. On the other hand, he was told that Mutt’s mother was Marion and
he didn’t take that in. Anyway. There’s a sub-plot about a guy who was going to
marry Helena. And she owes him money. Lots of chases. None of them memorable.
And then Antonio Banderas shows up as one of
Indy’s instant character friends. He should have made big Puss-in-Boots eyes. Spoiler alert. This whole sequence was shit.
Spielberg directed JAWS, written by
Robert Benchley’s son Peter. Peter Benchley wrote The Deep. That was a movie featuring JAWS star Robert Shaw.
I’m playing six degrees of ten variations on
something to do with Kevin Bacon. Basically, the idea of a treasure ship being
concealed by another treasure ship above it…that’s been done before. We don’t
quite get that here, but the earlier movie features a moray eel. And there are
CGI creatures in this timed-mission level that Indy must face…
Maybe it’s all the cartoony CGI from the
start of the movie. Indy looked like younger Indy as long as he didn’t turn his
head. But that train sequence was like a level in a computer game. And the
build-up to this underwater action sequence was…to tell us that they only had
three minutes.
After which, it’s back to the surface
and…Antonio Banderas fans, look away now.
I’m reminded of the villain’s ability to
keep turning up. Audiences didn’t turn up. The film took hundreds of millions
at the cinema and still rolled over and flopped.
Escape. Learn a few things. Oh, the
villain’s breathing down your necks again. Raid a tomb. Well that’s not very
ethical in the fifth movie in a series about thieving archaeologists. And then.
The hard part of the movie.
There are many variants of the Heinkel
bomber, so I suppose you could add one more to the pile without being noticed.
Of the thousands of aircraft built, there is a handful in existence today. Even
with his connections, where did low-rent Wernher von Braun grab a Heinkel from?
Did he just roll up to an air museum with a
bag full of thousand dollar bills and wink in a full German accent at the
museum curator? I’ll have it back by the
weekend, Mein Herr. Actually, that would work on the basis that you aren’t
coming back to this time. You are headed off to change history entirely.
So it is off to the past we go. And then
this ludicrous CGI battle in ancient history. With a bit of noodling and a load
of anti-climaxes. With one mighty punch, our hero was free. In the future
again.
There’s the payoff. Marion turns up for
reconciliation. When the actress starts bitching about how her role was
reduced, you know there were twenty-five-plus scripts for this shit. There’s
Sallah again. Blink and you miss him. Sallah’s contribution to this movie
starts to make the bridesmaid cameo in CRYSTAL
SKULL look appealing.
Spoiler alert for the end of the movie. Indy
hangs up his hat. But takes it back as the movie fades. It’s not the years.
Definitely the mileage. The tyres are gone and the wheels are worn down to
wishful thinking. Even the fumes in the tank are running on fumes.
Who thought this was a good idea and can we
use the dial of dullness to rewind? Normally, I write around 1,500 words in
these blog posts. But the computer tells me that I’ve exceeded 8,000. I cannot
apologise for my rambling rant. When the movie itself has no structure worth
reporting, I am forced to veer off into other things.
This film ends with Indy and Marion united
all over again. The payoff did not match the set-up. Faces did not match
bodies. Length of movie did not come close to original length of original
movie. The people involved in producing and directing this were snakes. Why did
it have to be snakes?